Directed by: Peter Farrelly
Written by: Peter Gamble
Starring: Anthony Ippolito, AnnaSophia Robb, Toby Kebbell, P.J. Byrne, Kiki Seto, Tracy Letts, Stephan James, Jay Duplass, and Matt Dillon
Runtime: 128 minutes
‘I Play Rocky’: Ippolito delivers a knockout as Stallone in this insightful and crowd-pleasing trip to the movies
John Rambo
Marion Cobretti
Barney Ross
Lincoln Hawk
Freddy Heflin
Dwight ‘The General’ Manfredi
Judge Dredd
These are some of the characters that Hollywood legend Sylvester Stallone has played over his 50-plus years on the big and small screens, however, it was his role as Rocky Balboa in “Rocky” (1976) that – obviously - catapulted this Big Apple native into stardom.
The mere mention of the name Rocky Balboa will spark inspiring feelings of facing overwhelming odds, the American flag, and composer Bill Conti’s “Rocky” theme song (“Da, da, daaaaaa. Da, da, daaaaaa.”).
Six “Rocky” and three “Creed” flicks punched their way to the big screen from 1976 to 2023, but Stallone had to throw haymakers the size of The Spectrum, the former 18,000-seat home to the Philadelphia 76ers, to star in “Rocky”, a film that earned him two Oscar nominations, one for Best Actor and another for Best Screenplay. (And the movie won Best Picture!)
Millions upon millions of casual movie fans, sports diehards, and cinephiles have enjoyed the “Rocky” films over the decades, but how many know Stallone’s backstory and his sheer will to bring his screenplay about (and to star as) the ultimate underdog facing the Heavyweight Boxing Champion of the World to movie theatres?
After experiencing director Peter Farrelly’s “I Play Rocky”, the same moviegoers will be thrilled to realize that Rocky Balboa’s perseverance on-screen equals Sylvester’s determination off it.
“I Play Rocky” is a joyous, wondrous biopic.
The man stepping into Sly’s shoes – and boxing shoes - is 27-year-old Anthony Ippolito, and let’s call out it now: Ippolito is uncanny as Stallone.
Ippolito speaks, moves, and looks like a reincarnated copy of the original.
It’s a fabulous performance, as Anthony taps into Sylvester’s drive and dear care for his beliefs.
The general public (including me) has a perspective of Stallone as a valiant, muscle-bound, action-movie star, but “I Play Rocky” features his gentle, soft-spoken humanity. He walked to the opposite corner in the ring of life from his stern, critical, and sometimes abusive father, Frank (Matt Dillon).
Farrelly and screenwriter Peter Gamble’s flick is set during the lean years, Sly winning over two producers – Irwin Winkler (P. J. Byrne) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell) – with his “Rocky” script, and then the making of the film.
This 2026 movie’s tones, however, noticeably change between BWR and AWR, otherwise known in this review as Before Writing “Rocky” and After Writing “Rocky”. During BWR, Stallone’s story soaks in empathy, as he suffers internal churn from economic pain, including a difficult thread regarding a pet.
However, you might remember more of this movie’s bliss due to the AWR period, which features hilarious bombshell surprises from a couple of key “Rocky” cast members and delightful insight into the filmmakers crafting this fictional Philadelphian’s blue-collar journey and miraculous step into the squared circle.
Through it all, Sylvester’s wife, Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb), believes in him and is his rock, and Ippolito and Robb share loving chemistry and effectively communicate support at home.
Byrne and Kebbell keep up a brisk pace during the 128-minute runtime, and Jay Duplass and Tracy Letts nicely drop in for Hollywood realities and cynicism as director John Avildsen and studio executive Sandy Maddox, respectively. Kiki Seto, Robert Morgan, and Scot Teller play Talia Shire, Burgess Meredith, and Burt Young, but Stephan James is a fantastic, charismatic force as Carl Weathers.
“I Play Rocky” is a crowd-pleasing trip to the movies. You don’t need to see “Rocky” immediately beforehand, but after watching this film, you might be compelled to find the 1977 Best Picture Oscar winner on a streaming service, look to purchase a Blu-ray, or dig through the garage for your “Rocky” VHS cassette.
Jeff’s ranking
3.5 / 4 stars
